is adamant that we will only share deals that we think will truly save you money. To support our work, we do make money from some links to companies and deals on our site, which helps to pay our bills and support our Consumer Action Center. Learn more about our guarantee here.
Expired Deal
Expired Deal

11 uses for Dollar Tree’s cheaper alternative to Mr. Clean Magic Eraser

11 uses for Dollar Tree’s cheaper alternative to Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
Get This Deal Read More
Mike Timmermann |
Problem with a deal? Let us know.

If you’ve ever used Mr. Clean Magic Eraser around the house, you’re definitely a believer in magic!

Just add water and these powerful pads go to work on stubborn dirt, grime and grease, requiring only a little bit of scrubbing to get the job done.

So what’s Mr. Clean’s secret? It's melamine foam, the material that makes up the sponges.

Read more: This dollar store hack will save money on Swiffer pads

Are cheaper versions of Mr. Clean Magic Eraser worth it?

In a YouTube video, Kim from This Old Homestead demonstrated how a cheaper version of the product erased permanent marker from her counter.

Kim said you can buy melamine foam on Amazon for about $0.49 a pad. 


But do the generic versions of Mr. Clean Magic Eraser really work as well as the original? I decided to try Dollar Tree’s Scrub Buddies Quick Eraser sponges.

Here’s a look at how the product brightened up an old shoe:

XX uses for Dollar Tree's cheaper version of Mr. Clean Magic Eraser

I would say that Dollar Tree’s eraser fell apart quicker than Mr. Clean’s product normally does, but I was able to clean two pairs of shoes with one eraser.

The sponges come in a pack of two at the dollar store, so $0.50 each. A check of shows that a 4-pack of Mr. Clean Magic Eraser sells for $3.47, which is $0.87 each.

My verdict: Scrub Buddies Quick Erasers are definitely worth the money!

Scrub Buddies vs. Mr. Clean

You don’t have to take my word for it because I found another YouTuber named Lori who recorded a video to compare how the two erasers performed around her house: 

  • Bathroom sink film: Neither worked
  • Scuff mark on door: Both worked
  • Kitchen sink marks: Both worked

In the end, Lori said the Scrub Buddies eraser worked just as well as Mr. Clean, and she gave it a 4 out of a 5.


There are many uses for these erasers! 

If you’ve never tried Scrub Buddies Quick Erasers (or a similar product), you may not realize how much of a lifesaver these pads can really be!

Here are 11 tough jobs they can tackle with no added cleaning products:

  1. Remove scuff marks on doors, floors and baseboards
  2. Clean grout
  3. Brighten sneakers
  4. Remove soap scum
  5. Erase permanent marker, pencil and crayon marks
  6. Remove rust marks
  7. Clean kitchen appliances
  8. Stain removal, including furniture and carpet
  9. Wipe away stove grease
  10. Pick up stuck on dirt
  11. Clean toys

It's recommended that you test the eraser in an inconspicuous area to see if the surface will dull or scratch.

And since these budget-friendly erasers won’t work on everything, we’ve put together a list of 30 home cleaning hacks that will transform your routine.

Read more: Putting the Dollar Tree cleaner 'LA's Totally Awesome' to the test!